Skip to content

Posts tagged ‘poverty’

India: A Land of Contradiction

I came to India to see how people here live – day to day. How important is commerce, religion, family? What I’ve found is that India is not that different from Europe or the United States. Their concerns are the same as ours. Religion here ranges from the superficial to the profound; commerce is the engine that drives the country; and family is very important. I wasn’t sure what to expect and perhaps expecting something different was a little silly in hindsight. I tend to focus on commonality rather than differences but here are some differences:

  • The people here are incredibly curious – curious about everything. I’m a minority here and get lots stares and smiles. When I am filming or taking pictures complete strangers walk up and want me to take their picture. It’s inexplicable to me.
  • There is no concept of waiting in line. There are so many people competing for attention that the solution is to just rush any service counter and push until you get to the front. It’s not considered rude – it’s just the way it is.
  • Traffic follows pretty much the same rules. If you can squeeze in between two lanes of traffic in the middle, go for it! Surprisingly, I’ve yet to see any serious accidents. There are dividing lines on the road but they are a complete waste of paint. There are also traffic lights but they are largely ignored unless a few police officers are directing traffic. The power grid goes down so often that you can easily understand why people ignore the traffic lights – most of the time they do not even work.
  • The poverty is everywhere. In fact, it is so ubiquitous that it’s easy to ignore. It appears the poorest people do not do most of the begging because they are busy doing whatever jobs they can find. The state hires street sweepers – not the big machines like in the US – to sweep the streets with straw brooms. They are everywhere sweeping away. In a dusty city like Delhi, it’s an endless job. I’ll have to write more about poverty later as I haven’t had a chance to really mentally process this side of India.
  • Construction is everywhere. You can see the tangible results of the massive influx of money into India. There is no doubt that India’s potential is yet to be tapped.
  • I’ve also discovered that there is no reason to learn Hindi if you want to do business in India. Everyone with a college education speaks English and there are enough signs in English that an American can easily find their way around. However, without knowing Hindi you really miss out on the heart of the culture. Most of the working class do not speak English and that’s the majority of the population – at least in Delhi. If you want to understand India, you’ll have to learn the language.

That’s all I’ve got for now. I will write more later…

Why I am a Liberal

“Give me your tired, your poor, Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, The wretched refuse of your teeming shore. Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me, I lift my lamp beside the golden door!” – by Emma Lazarus (on the plaque at the base of the Statue of Liberty)

Today is Blog Action Day ’08 – a day when bloggers around the world decide to write about one topic – poverty. Lately, I’ve been finding myself having to explain to my more conservative friends why I am a liberal. As much as I hate labels, it appears that this one fits. There are a few ideological reasons for believing one approach is better than another. Here are two …

On Welfare
In America, we currently have two welfare systems – social and corporate. A common argument against liberalism is the social welfare system. The argument goes that giving to the poor will encourage them to remain in poverty so that they can continue getting free money. There is probably much merit in this argument but I have been lucky enough in my life to not have to stand in line for food stamps to feed my children. Of course, we also have corporate welfare. In fact, we have just seen a great example of this in the latest banking bailout. We’re giving the banking industry $700,000,000,000. That’s enough money to start our own space program and build a fleet of 45 space shuttles. Looked at another way, it’s enough money to feed the poor around the world for the next 100 years. I only wish there was a check box when I filed my taxes every year that asked me if I would rather give money to big business or to the poor. Of course, most people would check “give to the poor”. That is one reason I am considered liberal – if my money is going to be redistributed, I would much rather it be redistributed to poor people rather than rich people.

On Healthcare
We have a amazing healthcare system in the United States. It has kept me healthy and even saved my life once. I’ve been lucky enough to have excellent healthcare and insurance either free or very cheap. There are a lot of people that do not have this option. Because the rest of us have our family physician we don’t have to spend hours in a waiting in the ER for a doctor to see our sick child. It’s a problem that is out of sight, out of mind. The number one reason Americans file for bankruptcy is healthcare costs. Those same people who are currently against a subsidized healthcare system may feel differently if they are diagnosed with cancer someday only to find their insurance company drop them. This happens all too often. Call me liberal, but I would rather my tax dollars go to build an affordable healthcare system rather than those same dollars going to subsidize large pharmaceutical companies.

Sources:
“Who Pays the Most Taxes?”
Study says most corporations pay no U.S. income taxes